And it wasn’t just the trees—shrubs, vines, weeds, saplings, and pretty much any other living thing was scraped clean from the railroad tracks to the canal bank (See photos.) So what was this all about?
Ask just about anyone in Lambertville familiar with the situation and they’ll tell you, “It’s the railroad!” To many surprised residents the recent tree and brush clearing appeared to be an effort to clear the overgrown and unused railroad tracks for the “Tourist Train” proposed by Black River and Western Railroad. BRWR hopes to run on weekends behind Clinton Street, over the “Nifti” Bridge behind Rojo’s Roastery and the Roxy Ballet Studio, passing over Alexauken Creek and proceeding to Ringoes and Flemington and back.
Despite appearances, according to several authorities, officially, the clearing work is unrelated to the railroad.
Why so much confusion? No signs, no notices—Work began abruptly in December of 2018 with no apparent advance notice provided to residents or local businesses, nor to the officials of the City of Lambertville. No signs were posted on the canal path. Similar work had been performed some years ago closer to Bridge Street, but the recent work was more “thorough”— or drastic, depending on your perspective—this time only a few trees were allowed to remain.
Concerned citizens contacted Lambertville City authorities, discovered that they had no information about the project, and were referred to the Delaware & Raritan Canal Commission.
Delaware & Raritan Canal Commission Executive Director, John Hutchison, explained “the project is being undertaken by the NJ Water Supply Authority pursuant to the 1986 lease agreement with the State” for the purpose of clearing the canal and maintaining the water flow. He explained, “Jurisdiction over the D&R Canal is somewhat complex…”
The New Jersey Water Supply Authority (“NJWSA”) has jurisdiction over the D&R Canal Water Transmission Complex (“Transmission Complex”), as defined here.
The New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection’s State Park Service (“NJDEP”) has jurisdiction over the D&R Canal State Park (“Park”), defined as the State-owned lands along the Canal Banks.
The Delaware & Raritan Canal Commission (“DRCC”) has jurisdiction over the entire State-owned D&R Canal and Commission Review Zones.
“I hope this information is useful. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Also, the Commission meets monthly to review project applications and our meetings always include a public comment portion. The Commission meets the third Wednesday of the month at 10:00 a.m. in the Prallsville Mill Complex in Stockton.” — John Hutchison, Executive Director D&R Canal Commission
D&R Canal State Park Superintendent Patricia Kallesser met one Lambertville resident and explained that this ongoing work of the NJWSA had to do with maintaining the water flow in the canal and upkeep of the historical (stone wall) structures. When asked about the lack of communication, she explained that the NJWSA web site maintained a FAQ about it on their web site.
From: Christopher Plummer
Sent: Tuesday, January 1, 2019 10:54 AM
Subject: Please consider local interests w/Canal Brush and Tree Clearing in and around Lambertville
Dear NJ Water Services Authority,
I, and other residents, merchants, and “canal walkers” were very surprised by the recent clearing of over 100 trees, some large, 20-30 years old, and the “buzz cutting” of brush and shrubs from the railroad tracks to the edge of the canal starting near Finkel’s Hardware on Coryell Street and moving North on the West side of the canal. This work adversely impacted:
- Bird and animal life and habitat prized by many residents, businesses, and tourists.
- Local Visual aesthetics, exposing parking lots and warehouses that were screened by foliage, leaving a trail of tree stumps and giving that section of the canal an industrial appearance that had previously been “natural”.
- Noise – the elimination of trees and shrubs that provided an acoustic buffer to the noise from the river recreation, roads, and New Hope.
May I suggest in the future:
- Inform the public with accurate information about the purpose, scope, schedule, and likely impact of the work by posting signs on the canal path and in local papers, and phone calls to local officials.
- Provide time and a means for those concerned to give feedback before the work is started.
- Please give some weight and consideration to those concerns and find a balance between the preservation of historical structures and the preservation of current flora and wildlife habitat.
Thank you for your consideration, and best wishes for the New Year.
From: info <firstname.lastname@example.org>Subject: RE: Please consider local interests w/Canal Brush and Tree Clearing in and around LambertvilleDate: January 18, 2019 at 11:24:00 AM ESTTo: ‘Christopher Plummer’Dear Mr. Plummer,
Thank you for your concerned email and our apologies for the delay in response. And thank you for your suggestions on future public notification, which we will certainly take under advisement.
As you know, the Authority’s mission is to maintain a flow of water through the Canal to provide raw water supply for our customers. Our Canal maintenance crews and engineers need to “see” the embankment. Seeing the embankment often helps us to prevent damage to the embankment that may develop from tree roots or animal burrows which can lead to seepage paths or from damage when the trees fall and their root balls remove sections of the embankment. The Authority’s needs to see the embankment are constantly balanced with the wants and needs of Canal park walkers, joggers, bikers, nature enthusiasts, fishermen, historians, neighbors, and others [My emphasis—Christo] , all of whom may have a different idea of what maintenance should look like on the 60 plus mile Canal. We tried to provide an understanding of our work in the FAQ’s that were recently posted on the website.
For the upcoming winter work on the Canal in Lambertville, crews may begin again as early as the week of January 21, 2019. The exact schedule for the winter maintenance is weather dependent, and subject to equipment and personnel availability, and will include the following (in no particular order):
- Thin-out the underbrush and small trees on the western bank and in and on the stone wall between Coryell Street and Bridge Street.
- Clearing the vegetation from the Lambertville lock walls.
- Felling three Ash trees from the east side of the Canal, upstream of the Lambertville Lock.
- Removing the trees growing from the stone wall, on the river side of the embankment, from the wing dam (in the River) and downstream.Items #1 thru #3 should only take several days each and should be completed this winter.Item #4 will take quite a bit of time and will most likely occur over several years depending on other emergent items that need to be addressed and may stop and restart within the same year.Feel free to share this information with other concerned residents.(No sender name identified)
I Guess that was the Public Notice. I forwarded a copy to the City of Lambertville. I haven’t seen any new notices or additional information about the canal work. Have you? The NJWSA is apparently continuing their work up the south end of town as described in the email.
Local railroad supporters on Facebook are urging residents not to “listen to rumors” and espousing the wonders of bringing the iron horse, full of tourists, to Lambertville to reinvigorate our little town.
🚂 Meanwhile if it quacks like a duck… At the North end of town small crews and individuals with mowers and chainsaws are clearing the railroad tracks. They make no pretense about working for the Water Authority.
Feb. 26, 2019 Tuesday – Today NJWRA trucks and teams are clearing the rails and canal, between Coryell and Bridge, chipping as they go.
—By the way, the empty nest this late in the season suggests that Bald Eagles will not be nesting on the power tower over Alexauken Creek this year. In 2017 they raised three fledglings at the site, not far from the “Nifti” Railroad Bridge and abandoned rail car at the north end of the trail in Lambertville.
Residents who wish to communicate their concerns about the destruction of wildlife habitat, the need for trees and brush as a visual screen and natural noise buffer, and other concerns are urged to contact any or all of the individuals and organizations below:
The City of Lambertville
Mayor Julia Fahl
18 York Street
Lambertville, NJ 08530
“Ask the Mayor”